Design an Experiment: The Effects of Temperature on Lactase Activity Introduction Enzymes are a class of protein molecules that act as biological catalysts. You may already know some properties of chemical catalysts. They increase the rate of a reaction, but are not used up in the reaction. Enzymes share these features with chemical catalysts, but also have some important differences. One of the most important differences is that enzymes are usually much more specific than chemical catalysts. Enzymes recognize particular reactant molecules, called substrates, and convert them into products. In contrast, chemical catalysts usually act on a broad range of reactants. In an enzymatic reaction, the enzyme “recognizes” the substrate by its shape and by the position of its hydrogen bonding sites and binds the substrate to itself at the active site. Once at the active site, the substrate rapidly undergoes the enzyme catalyzed reaction. The enzyme you will be studying in this experiment is lactase, and the reaction it catalyzes is the hydrolysis of the disaccharide lactose into the monosaccharides galactose and glucose. Humans require this enzyme for digestion of lactose found in milk and other dairy products. The medical condition known as lactose intolerance results when the body produces insufficient amounts of lactase to digest the lactose found in these foods. Lactose intolerance can cause intestinal discomfort and symptoms such as cramps, bloating and diarrhea. In the dairy case at the grocery store, you may have noticed “lactose-free” milk. This type of milk has lactase enzyme added to it to hydrolyze the lactose before you drink it. Individuals with lactose intolerance can then enjoy the benefits of milk without the unpleasant side effects.
In this experiment, you will monitor the enzyme activity by determining how much glucose has formed. Because glucose is a product of lactose hydrolysis, measuring the amount of glucose gives a direct measurement of how much lactose has reacted. You will monitor the enzyme activity using test strips that measure the level of glucose in the reaction mixture. These are the same strips that diabetics use to monitor glucose levels with a home test kit. The presence of glucose in solution will change the test strip from a blue-green color to dark brown. Adapted by N. Berg, NNHS ©2011 From: http://capital2.capital.edu/faculty/wbecktel/Enzyme.htm and http://www.learnnc.org/
PRE-LAB QUESTIONS 1. How are enzymes and chemical catalysts similar? They are similar in that they both change the rate of the reaction but remain unchanged once the reaction is completed. 2. How are enzymes and chemical catalysts different? Enzymes are different from chemical catalysts in that they bind to specific reactants (substrates) whereas chemical catalysts work with a wide range of reactants. 3. Lactose is composed of what two monosaccharides? G alactose and Glucose 4. How does the industry make “lactose-free” milk? They add extra lactase molecules to hydrolyze, or separate, the lactose molecule so that persons who are lactose-intolerant can ingest milk without side effects. 5. In this experiment, how will you know how much lactose reacted? B y the concentration of glucose molecules, since glucose is a direct product of lactose. 6. If glucose is present in a solution, what color change will you notice on a glucose test strip? Blue-green to dark brown color change.
We will be using the Engineering Design Process to design this experiment. A few things to note for this experiment: ●
●
● ● ●
Each group table will have either a beaker of ice water or a beaker of water on a hot plate. Use caution when around the hot plates - the beaker, water, and the hot plate can burn you! Each group will prepare the lactase solution that they will be using for the experiment. To do this, crush one lactase enzyme tablet with the pill crusher and add it to 200 mL of water. Stir until dissolved. Test samples will be placed in the microfuge tubes Forceps will be used to remove the microfuge tubes from the ice water and hot water baths. The temperatures we will be testing are 0℃, 25℃, 40℃, 60℃, and 80℃. Each table will have one of these conditions. The Lactase solution in the microfuge tubes should sit in the water bath for 5 minutes (Make sure the cap snaps shut before placing it in the water!).
To help you design the experiment, determine the following: ASK 1. What is the problem? Design an experiment that examines the effects of temperature on lactase activity. Adapted by N. Berg, NNHS ©2011 From: http://capital2.capital.edu/faculty/wbecktel/Enzyme.htm and http://www.learnnc.org/
2. What are the requirements? Use the Engineering Design Process, Use the materials provided, be able to observe the glucose levels 3. What are the constraints? Has to take place within a class period, temperature 4. Conduct research to find information on the subject and possibly even articles describing previous experiments that have investigated this same problem. Summarize your research below (Be sure to cite the source in APA format). The enzyme lactase, acts as a catalyst at which to break down lactose into galactose and glucose. Like many enzymes, lactase works best in its most optimal conditions. Those conditions tend to be primarily affected by temperature and pH to which the enzyme can be denatured if the change is large enough. For temperature, this means that if it exceeds or goes below the range of 70 to 120 degrees Fahrenheit, the enzyme can be altered. Low temperatures tend to slow down the reaction while extremely high temperatures denature the enzyme. pH, to which the working range is between 2 to 7 can be altered with extreme shifts as well. Typically, shifts that lie above the range to to result in the lactase enzyme becoming denatured. Seattlepi. (n.d.). The Effects of PH and Temperature on Enzyme Activity of Lactase on Lactose. Retrieved October 17, 2017, from http://education.seattlepi.com/effects-ph-temperature-enzyme-activity-lactase-lac ose-734.html
5. Write a hypothesis for this experiment. If the temperature increases then the amount of lactase activity will increase. IMAGINE Brainstorm/whiteboard with your group a plan of action in order to perform an experiment that will help you answer the problem. 5. Insert a picture of your brainstorming whiteboard.
Adapted by N. Berg, NNHS ©2011 From: http://capital2.capital.edu/faculty/wbecktel/Enzyme.htm and http://www.learnnc.org/
6. What steps were decided upon early in the process? Which steps were more difficult to agree upon? Most of the steps were decided upon pretty early however we had a bit of difficulty with deciding upon the sixth step. PLAN 7. List the materials that you will be using below (Follow the Formal Lab Report Guidelines!). ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ●
1% milk, 0.5 mL Water, 600 mL Hot plate Ice, Timer Lactase Solution (Dairy Relief), Pipettes, 2 Diastix (Glucose test strips), 5 Pill Crusher Forceps Stir Rod Goggles Microcentrifuge tubes, 5 Beakers, 6
Adapted by N. Berg, NNHS ©2011 From: http://capital2.capital.edu/faculty/wbecktel/Enzyme.htm and http://www.learnnc.org/
● Sharpie ● Thermometer 8. Write the steps in your procedure below (Follow the Formal Lab Report Guidelines!). G et teacher approval before you move on to the next stage of the EDP. Handling Procedures: Hot plate: Make sure that the hot plate is only transferred when turned off and fully cooled. Avoid touching when hot. Beaker (hot): Use tongs to move the beaker on the plate. Only move the beaker when it is fully cooled. Safety Instructions: Wear goggles for the duration of the experiment.
Procedure: Turn on the hot plate. Be careful the plate will be hot. Fill beaker with 200mL of water. Use the pill crusher to crush one lactase enzyme tablet. Pour the crushed tablet into 200mL of water. Stir until dissolved. Using a pipette, add 0.5 ml dissolved substance in the microfuge tubes. Fill another beaker with water and place on the hot plate. Once heated to one of the following temperatures: 0 degrees Celsius, 25 degrees Celsius, 40 degrees Celsius, 60 degrees Celsius, and 80 degrees Celsius, place the microfuge tube into the beaker for 5 minutes. Label all centrifuges with its assigned temperature and the lab person’s initials (if there is more than one experimental group). Make sure the cap is fully closed before placing in the water bath. 7. Using the forceps, remove the microfuge from the beaker. Be careful when removing the microfuge as it is hot. 8. Pour milk into an additional container. Then, using a pipette, add 0.5 ml of 1% milk into the centrifuge. Wait 2 minutes until the enzyme fully hydrolyzes the lactase. 9. Place one diastix into centrifuge until half soaked then slide the strip onto the side of the centrifuge. Wait 30 seconds for the diastix to set and compare the color of the stick to the colors listed on the packaging. Write down the results of the glucose test trip for each temperature in the table provided. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
CREATE Conduct your experiment by following your written procedure. Collect and write your data in Figure 1. Adapted by N. Berg, NNHS ©2011 From: http://capital2.capital.edu/faculty/wbecktel/Enzyme.htm and http://www.learnnc.org/
Figure 1. 0℃ Amount of Glucose (g/dL)
1/4
25℃ 1/2
40℃ 1/10
60℃ 1/10
80℃ 1/10
9. Insert a line graph of Figure 1. Include a title and X- and Y-axis labels with units.
Analysis 10. What temperature resulted in a loss of enzymatic activity? 25℃ 11. Explain what most likely contributed to the loss of enzymatic activity at each temperature. It is likely there was a loss of enzymatic activity at higher temperatures since this particular enzyme works best in relatively low Adapted by N. Berg, NNHS ©2011 From: http://capital2.capital.edu/faculty/wbecktel/Enzyme.htm and http://www.learnnc.org/
temperatures. At higher temperatures, the amount of lactose molecules broken down has likely reached its saturation. This means that the lactase enzyme cannot perform any more reactions and thus decrease its enzymatic activity. 12. Summarize the effect of temperature on the production of glucose. Based on the results, it can be concluded that as the temperature surrounding the enzyme increases, glucose production decreases. IMPROVE 13. What were some design errors/flaws that occurred with your experiment? One noticeable design error was that it wasn’t specified in the directions whether the beakers provided would be for each experimental group rather than all experimental groups. In class, the beakers used to heat the centrifuges were distributed throughout all experimental groups. This made it difficult to properly ascertain the temperature, since some groups may not have had their beakers in a timely manner to their designated temperature. Either we had to wait for the beaker to cool down/warm up or simply place the centrifuge in at the improper temperature. We chose the latter and this may have resulted in some variation in our results. 14. What are some possible solutions to those design errors/flaws? P erhaps allowing each experimental group to have their own six beakers instead of distributing them throughout the classroom can better control waiting times to a singular area, thereby ensuring that the group doesn’t have to wait too long for another in order to heat their centrifuges.
Adapted by N. Berg, NNHS ©2011 From: http://capital2.capital.edu/faculty/wbecktel/Enzyme.htm and http://www.learnnc.org/